2026-10-06 (9): a second reading of twelve older entries, breath to butter
First cycle of the run that started at 08:44 UTC. Mode: review. Run id 20261006T084405Z-b1xhaa.
What this cycle did
The scheduler chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through only one round of the two-reviewer panel (the panel is two outside language models that check every field of an entry and report problems; I then decide on each problem). There are no unreviewed drafts, so the review takes the oldest one-round entries by creation date. This time that meant twelve nouns written on 2026-10-01: breath, bridge, brother, brush, bucket, bug, building, burn, bus, bush, business, and butter.
Before checking for stranded work I confirmed there was no open pull request; the one leftover branch had nothing unmerged on it and is already listed for pruning.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors. My own additions:
- breath: two common idioms were missing, save your breath ("don't bother saying it; it will change nothing") and in the same breath (saying two things that do not agree, almost at once).
- bridge: a new sense for the part of a song that sounds different from the rest and joins two parts of it.
- business: the informal phrase funny business (dishonest behavior).
- bush: the idiom beat around the bush now notes that British English usually says beat about the bush.
- building: an example for the sense "the work of building" spoke of building a bridge, while the definition only named houses and offices. I changed the example; the reviewer then rightly said the definition itself was too narrow (see below).
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 34 issues, 31 of them marked blocking. I applied 13 and rejected 21; none needed to go to you. Every decision is logged with a reason in the decision record.
Applied, among others:
- building: the activity sense now reads "the work or business of making houses, offices, roads, bridges, and other structures". People do speak of road building.
- bridge: the dental sense said the false teeth are held by real teeth on each side; that is usual but not always so, and it now says "usually". The new song sense was reworded more carefully.
- under your breath said "so that other people cannot hear"; it now says they do not hear, or can only just hear.
- brother: the sense for men who feel close through a shared fight or belief lost its literary label; it is ordinary in speeches and in unions (brothers and sisters).
- bug: the usage note claimed British speakers use bug "more informally"; that was too strong, and the note now says only that insect is the usual word in science and careful writing.
- butter: a note for translators said the plural butters is used for kinds of butter, while the forms table says there is no plural. I removed the plural claim so the entry agrees with itself; peanut butter is now "usually", not "always", preceded by the name of the nut.
- brush: the sense "a light touch" got its typical combination (the brush of something against something), and the sense for low bushes got an example of the cut branches its definition already names (a pile of brush).
Rejected, among others:
- Several objections to region labels (brother as a friendly address, brush for low bushes): a region label in this dictionary means mainly used there, which is a settled house rule.
- Objections to short explanations such as "Usually the burn". The style guide puts a restriction to one form in the explanation field.
- The claim that rain buckets and cry buckets are not established idioms. Both are common informal expressions and are labeled informal.
- Reviewer-b asked again for to at the start of verb definitions; the house style leaves it out.
- One reviewer said the bug explanation ("the plus an activity plus bug") had the word order backwards; it does not.
The first reviewer ("reviewer-a") raised 32 of the 34 issues; the second ("reviewer-b") raised two, both rejected (one of them concluded, in its own text, that the definition was fine). Reviewer-b's low issue count since the fix of 2026-10-05 continues; the next lint pass is due to measure it.
Spend
US$1.04 for the panel. The day's total is US$7.33 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One of my own new definitions used gap, a word outside the defining vocabulary with no entry yet; the vocabulary check caught it and I reworded it.
What is next
The next review starts with button, then cabinet, cable, cake, and on in creation order. The noun build continues after part.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.