2026-10-06 (6): a second reading of twelve older entries, boot to breakfast
Second cycle of the run that started at 04:44 UTC. Mode: review. Run id 20261006T044809Z-favc2y.
What this cycle did
The scheduler chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through only one round of the two-reviewer panel (the panel is two outside language models that check every field of an entry and report problems; I then decide on each problem). There are no unreviewed drafts, so the review takes the oldest one-round entries by creation date. This time that meant twelve nouns written on 2026-10-01: boot, boss, bottle, bottom, bowl, box, boy, brain, branch, bread, break, and breakfast.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors, and for breaches of the house style. The entries were in good shape. My own changes were small:
- An example under boy (the sense for a male pet) named the dog Max. The style guide allows only nine personal names in examples, so it now reads Is your dog a boy or a girl? Another boy example used the British-leaning film star; it now says movie star.
- The bottle sense for babies defined a bottle as "a bottle with a soft top", which uses the word to define itself. It now begins "a small container with a soft top".
- He hurt his brain in a bad fall is not something people say; it is now The fall caused serious damage to his brain.
- Each branch of the army has its own uniform was not quite right (the army is itself one branch of the armed forces); it now reads The navy is one branch of the armed forces.
- Two word-combination lists got a better item: report to your boss instead of work for a boss, and a continental breakfast.
Then both reviewer models read every field again.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 31 issues. I applied 12 and rejected 19; every decision is logged with a reason in the decision record. None needed to go to you.
Applied, among others:
- branch: both reviewers said chapter is not a synonym of branch in the sense "one part of a subject, an organization, or a family". They are right (a chapter is a local group of a club, a much narrower thing). I removed the link from branch and also the matching link back from chapter, since otherwise the next housekeeping pass would put it back.
- boy, the pet sense, said "especially a pet dog or a horse". Good boy! is said mostly to dogs; the horse is gone.
- boss: the usage note said people "rarely" call their boss boss to their face. That is too strong; the note now says some people do, in a friendly, informal way (Thanks, boss!). The note for translators on the false friend chef now says a chef is a skilled cook in a restaurant or hotel kitchen, not "only a cook in a restaurant".
- bottle: the senses for drinking alcohol (hit the bottle) and, in British English, courage (lose your bottle) had no lists of typical word combinations. Both have them now. The first definition was reworded to avoid ending on a stranded in.
- box: the post-office-box example now uses the form people actually write, our PO box.
Rejected, among others:
- Moving the idiom to boot ("as well") out of the boot entry. The house rule puts an idiom under its keyword noun whatever its grammar; this is a settled point.
- Four objections to bread: that Can I have a bread? and two breads are sometimes acceptable. The entry already says breads means kinds of bread; a single loaf or slice called a bread is a real and common learner error.
- Calling the bottom of the class and the bottom of the garden countable. These uses only occur with the, in the singular.
- Calling use your brain uncountable. Your brain there is an ordinary singular countable noun.
The second reviewer ("reviewer-b") answered every field on all twelve entries; the fix to its partial replies, made on 2026-10-05, continues to hold.
Spend
US$1.10 for the panel. The day's total is US$4.44 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
One slip of mine: while checking a command's options I logged a test decision line by accident. I removed it before committing; the record holds only the 31 real decisions.
What is next
The next review takes breath, bridge, brother, brush, and the entries after them in creation order. The noun build continues after officer.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.