2026-10-06 (22): a second reading of chain to cheese
Cycle 2 of the 20:44 UTC run. Mode: review (a second panel round on entries already marked reviewed). Run id 20261006T210625Z-drbl4m.
What this cycle did
Cycle 1 of this run (journal/2026-10-06-21.md, pull request #287) built twelve new nouns and merged. The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) then chose review. It gave as its reason that review had the largest "scheduler debt", meaning it was the mode furthest behind its share of past cycles. It allowed blocks of up to twenty entries, but the day's paid budget had only US$0.83 left. One panel round costs about US$0.08 to US$0.15 per entry, so I took eight entries. They were the oldest that had been through only one panel round: the nouns chain, chair, chance, change, chapter, character, charge, and cheese, all drafted on 2026-10-01.
First I read each entry myself, looking for missing senses, idioms, and the common mistakes learners make. All eight were in good shape. I added four things by hand:
- the American informal idiom pull someone's chain (make someone believe something untrue, as a joke) to chain;
- a learner error to chair, fell asleep on the armchair corrected to in the armchair, which matches the entry's existing usage note about sitting on or in a chair;
- a learner error to chapter, in the chapter 3 corrected to in chapter 3;
- cheesy to the word family of cheese.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Two outside models from different companies ("reviewer-a" and "reviewer-b") then read every field of each entry. Reviewer-b found nothing to object to. Reviewer-a raised eleven issues, nine of them "blocking" (they must be settled before an entry counts as reviewed). I checked each one and agreed with all eleven. Each fix is logged in reviews/decisions.jsonl:
- change: the sense meaning a change from one train or bus to another (the trip takes two hours with one change) is mainly British. American English usually says transfer, so the sense now carries a British label.
- chapter: the sense meaning a local branch of a club had an American label, but it is standard in British English too, so the label came off. The idiom chapter and verse is now defined as "all the exact details or facts about something". The old definition wrongly suggested it meant the source itself.
- character: the box that compares character and personality said character is only about moral qualities. That contradicted the entry's own first sense. It now says character covers all of a person's qualities and is the usual word when moral qualities matter.
- chance: one of its three learner errors called a big chance wrong. That is only a preference (a good chance is more usual), not an error, so I removed it.
- chain and charge: two sub-sense definitions were tightened. Jewelry chains are now "usually around the neck", and electric charge is now "the amount of electricity that a piece of matter has, which is either positive or negative".
The cross-reference tool added one back-link, from price (built in cycle 1) to charge. All the local checks passed: validation, the size caps, links, unit tests, the defining-vocabulary gate (definitions must use the core word list), and the cross-reference gate.
Spend
The panel cost about US$0.79. The day now stands at US$14.97 of the US$15 cap. The rules end a run when less than US$0.50 of the day's budget remains, because unpaid cycles would only re-check an unchanged dictionary. So this run stops after two cycles. The budget resets at UTC midnight.
What is next
The next review block starts with the oldest remaining one-round entries: chest, chicken, choice, church, circle, citizen and on, all from 2026-10-01. The next build continues the band 1 nouns at priest. The forty-eighth lint pass (the periodic consistency sweep) is due soon; the selector will choose it.
For the owner
Nothing needs you from this cycle.