2026-10-05 (19): have the helping verb gets its own entry; a second reading of bicycle to blade
Third cycle of the run that started at 16:43 UTC. Mode: review. Run id 20261005T170757Z-kb063q.
What this cycle did
The scheduler chose review: a second reading of entries that the outside reviewers have seen only once. I did two things.
1. The owner's ruling on helping verbs, second part. On 2026-10-05 the owner ruled that be, have, and do used as helping verbs ("auxiliary verbs") should each get their own entry, one per review cycle. Be was done this afternoon. This cycle did have.
The new entry have-aux has three senses:
- the perfect tenses (I have finished, They had already left, Have you ever seen snow?). The explanation says that the present perfect links the past with now, so it is not used with a finished time such as yesterday.
- after could, should, would, must, might, or to, talking about the past (You should have told me, She must have missed the bus, I'm sorry to have kept you waiting).
- the formal use at the start of a clause instead of if (Had I known you were coming, I would have cooked more), labeled formal.
It also has:
- a usage note on its forms, questions, negatives, and short answers, and on the short forms 's and 'd, which can also stand for is and would;
- three learner errors: I have seen him yesterday, You should of told me, and I have lived here since five years;
- a pronunciation note on the weak forms;
- a note for translators on the present perfect.
The verb entry have-v no longer has its perfect-tense sense. Its summary sentence, usage note, translator notes, pronunciation note, and "see also" list now point to the new entry, and the new entry points back. No other entry depended on the removed sense. do-aux is next, in a later review cycle.
2. A second reading of eight entries: bicycle, bike, bill, bird, birth, birthday, bit, blade. These were the oldest entries with only one review round. They were already full, with several senses, idioms, and learner errors each, so I added little: the idiom a bird's-eye view, a bird of prey and a flock of birds, and collocations on two senses that had none (a birthday for a company, the best bit of a film).
What the reviewers found and what I decided
I logged 44 decisions: 32 changes applied, 12 rejected, none sent to the owner.
Useful catches:
- bill: three fields said Americans ask for "the check" in a restaurant and British speakers for "the bill", as if each side used only one. Americans also often say bill, so all three now say so. The law sense now covers a change to an existing law as well as a new one.
- birthday: the entry treated a company's or a school's "birthday" as an odd, friendly use and pushed readers to anniversary. It is ordinary English, so the definition, the usage note, and the translator note now allow it, and anniversary is described as the more formal word.
- bit: love someone to bits is mainly British and is now labeled so. A sentence about where champing at the bit comes from was moved out of the explanation, since the house rule keeps origins in the etymology field only.
- birth: the translator note had a wrong form in italics, which the house rule does not allow. It was rewritten, and the learner-error note now says the verb birth exists but belongs mainly to medical or formal writing.
- bird: the learner error a bird crying was not really an error, so I replaced it with a common one: birds fly in the sky, not on it.
- have-v: two back-links (from make and take, about have a party and have a shower) were on the "own" sense. I moved them to the "do or experience" sense.
- have-aux: reviewer B was right that the plain form have in examples does not need a hand mark (the website marks it); has and had keep theirs.
Rejected, with reasons logged:
- Reviewer A said that to have met and having finished are not uses of the helping verb. They are: they are the same perfect have in its non-finite forms.
- Reviewer B asked for the forms of have-aux in the inflections table. The inflection tool writes no forms for helping verbs, as with be-aux; the usage note lists them.
- Reviewer B asked to move a bit (meaning slightly) to an adverb entry. The house rule keeps idioms under their key word whatever their part of speech.
- Reviewer A said the best bit is not British. The region label means mainly used there, and American speakers usually say part.
Reviewer B again returned only part of its answer on five of the ten entries (have-aux, bike, birthday, bit, blade). Have-aux was still partial after one re-run. I worked on the issues it did send.
One small irregularity: the claim tool refused to claim have|aux because the entry file already existed on disk when I tried. So there is no claim file for this cycle. No other run could have taken the word in the meantime, because the queue row was pending only for review cycles.
Spend
US$0.81 this cycle. The day's total is US$9.66 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
do-aux in the next review cycle. Next for a second reading: blame, blanket, block, blood, then alcohol and cheek. Reviewer B's partial answers still need the tool fix.
For the owner
Nothing new. The helping-verb split is two-thirds done.