2026-10-04 (2) — Closure: twelve words the dictionary already uses
Second cycle of the run that started 00:43 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work that ends in its own merged pull request.
What this cycle did
The mode selector chose closure. Closure work drafts words the dictionary already uses but does not yet define: words that appear inside existing definitions, words in an entry's family (related forms such as a verb for an existing noun), and cross-reference targets.
The closure rows. The queue's "closure" source held only five rows, all of them problem rows whose part of speech had been guessed by a script:
- Christian (noun) was released again. It cannot pass the vocabulary check until you decide whether proper names may appear in definitions (open question 7).
- deliberately had been queued as a noun. It is an adverb (it is used in the definition of ignore), so the noun row was marked as a duplicate and deliberately (adverb) was claimed and drafted instead, with two senses (on purpose; slowly and carefully), a note comparing it with on purpose and intentionally, and learner errors for by purpose and She deliberate ignored me.
- cheat, fail, and hollow had been queued as nouns because the words appear in definitions, where they are actually used as a verb or an adjective that already has an entry. Earlier runs released them each time, so they kept coming back. All three are real nouns, so this time I drafted them: cheat (a person who cheats, with a subsense for an unfaithful partner, and a code that gives an advantage in a computer game); fail (a British exam result, the informal a total fail, and the phrase without fail); hollow (a small area of low ground, and a hole or space inside something).
The family rows. The rest came from the "family" source: eight verbs that pair with nouns already in the dictionary. They are battle (try hard, fight in a war, compete, and the phrase battle it out), beach (bring a boat onto a beach; of whales, become stuck), beautify, bed (fix firmly in something; an old-fashioned informal sense), befriend, belt (hit hard, fasten, move fast), bench (keep a player out of a game; lift weights), and benefit (benefit from something, something benefits someone).
All twelve passed the full pipeline and are published as reviewed.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two outside reviewer models raised 35 issues, 19 of them blocking (must be settled before publishing). I applied 32 and rejected 3.
Applied, among others:
- bed (verb) had a sense "put young plants into the ground". The reviewer was right that the bare verb is rare for this; gardeners say bed out. The sense was removed and bed out is mentioned in the usage note instead. The note on bed down was also corrected: it means settle down to sleep somewhere unusual, not just sleep.
- cheat: I had called cheater "mainly American". It is more common there, but it is used in Britain too; the wording is softer now. The unfaithful-partner subsense was reworded, and the game sense no longer says the trick must be secret.
- bench: the weightlifting sense can be used without an object (How much do you bench?), so its grammar now allows that.
- beach: the whale sense now covers being left stuck, not only becoming stuck, and names seals as well.
- Smaller fixes to usage notes on fail, hollow, deliberately, battle, and beautify.
Rejected: three objections, all the same one, that the American transcription of beach should carry a length mark. The house style for American English leaves it out; this is settled.
The vocabulary check found five definition words outside the defining vocabulary (the list of about 2,400 plain words that definitions should use): rival, romantic, sexual, embarrassing, and curves. Those definitions were rewritten in plainer words.
The cross-reference tool added mirror links on seven existing entries; I checked them (battle landed on the "in a war" sense of fight, correctly).
Spend
US$0.34 for this cycle. Today's total is US$0.87 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One point for later: the "closure" source is now empty apart from Christian, so closure cycles will draw on the family and cross-reference sources from now on.
What is next
The selector decides the next cycle. Building continues with band-1 nouns after friend; about 470 entries are waiting for a second review round.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. Open question 7 (may proper names such as Christian appear in definitions?) is the one this cycle ran into again.