2026-10-04 (14) — review: second reading of write to appointment
Second cycle of the run that started at 12:44 UTC. Run id 20261004T130151Z-q1o26y.
What this cycle did
The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) chose review. A review is a second reading of entries that have been checked by the outside reviewers only once. The to-do list asks for the oldest of these first, so this cycle took the twelve oldest. They were written on 2026-09-30: the verbs write, wrap, and worry, and the nouns ambulance, amount, alphabet, angle, animal, anger, attack, apartment, and appointment.
Before sending them to the reviewers, I read each entry myself and looked for gaps that matter to a learner:
- Wrap gained a learner error for leaving out around (She wrapped a scarf her neck).
- Animal gained a learner error for using the when talking about animals in general.
- Appointment gained the phrase by appointment (open to visitors by appointment only).
The other nine entries already had their main senses, their common errors, and their notes in order. Nothing else needed adding.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
Two outside models, which we call reviewer-a and reviewer-b, read every field of every entry. Neither is from Anthropic. They raised 39 issues, 20 of them "blocking" (they must be settled before an entry is published). I applied 16 and rejected 23, each with a logged reason.
The useful catches:
- Sense 5 of write was defined as "fill in a check for someone, or a note from a doctor". That wording was clumsy and not quite right. It now reads "fill in and sign a check, or give someone a written order for medicine", and a short explanation says the second use belongs to doctors.
- Amount said flatly that a large amount of people is wrong. Many speakers do say it, though careful writers avoid it. The entry still teaches number with plural nouns, but now as the safe choice in careful English rather than a rule.
- Attack said the noun is always followed by on. For an illness or a feeling, of is common (an attack of nerves), and the note now says so.
- Worry mentioned a rare British use (a dog that worries sheep) inside the explanation of another sense. I removed it rather than give it a sense of its own.
- A few collocations were replaced with more typical ones: a fierce attack, wrap production, and pay the full amount. An example in appointment now uses the American word principal instead of head teacher.
Most rejections were the same house-rule objection as on earlier runs, made ten times. Reviewer-b wants the opening headword of an adaptation note in bold, not in quotation marks. The house style allows the quotation marks, and the to-do list says to reject this objection. Other rejections:
- Not to worry keeps its British label. A region label in this dictionary means "mainly used there".
- Worry and sorry do not rhyme in American English either, so the pronunciation note stays.
- Amount is itself a countable noun (an amount, large amounts), so its grammar is right.
- The everyday sense of animal that excludes birds and fish (birds and animals) stays as a sense, because the entry already explains that it is a loose use.
Reviewer-b's precision this cycle was very low, 0.1. That means only one of its ten issues was accepted, and nine of the ten were the adaptation-note objection. This is the low precision in the spelling-or-format family that the owner has already been asked about.
Spend
US$0.44 this cycle, for the two reviewers. The day's total is US$5.65 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One review decision was logged twice by mistake. I removed the duplicate line from the decision ledger (reviews/decisions.jsonl) before committing.
What is next
The next cycle's job is chosen by the selector. The next review in line starts with appearance, answer, art, and arrest, all written on 2026-09-30. A lint pass, the regular check of the whole dictionary and wiki for problems, is due in a cycle or two.
For the owner
Nothing new. The earlier questions still stand: whether to switch off the two low-precision reviewer checks (NEXT.md, "For the owner") and the seven open questions in wiki/open-questions.md.