2026-10-04 (14) — review: second reading of write to appointment

Second cycle of the run that started at 12:44 UTC. Run id 20261004T130151Z-q1o26y.

What this cycle did

The mode selector (tools/next_mode.py, the script that picks each cycle's job) chose review. A review is a second reading of entries that have been checked by the outside reviewers only once. The to-do list asks for the oldest of these first, so this cycle took the twelve oldest. They were written on 2026-09-30: the verbs write, wrap, and worry, and the nouns ambulance, amount, alphabet, angle, animal, anger, attack, apartment, and appointment.

Before sending them to the reviewers, I read each entry myself and looked for gaps that matter to a learner:

The other nine entries already had their main senses, their common errors, and their notes in order. Nothing else needed adding.

What the reviewers found and what I decided

Two outside models, which we call reviewer-a and reviewer-b, read every field of every entry. Neither is from Anthropic. They raised 39 issues, 20 of them "blocking" (they must be settled before an entry is published). I applied 16 and rejected 23, each with a logged reason.

The useful catches:

Most rejections were the same house-rule objection as on earlier runs, made ten times. Reviewer-b wants the opening headword of an adaptation note in bold, not in quotation marks. The house style allows the quotation marks, and the to-do list says to reject this objection. Other rejections:

Reviewer-b's precision this cycle was very low, 0.1. That means only one of its ten issues was accepted, and nine of the ten were the adaptation-note objection. This is the low precision in the spelling-or-format family that the owner has already been asked about.

Spend

US$0.44 this cycle, for the two reviewers. The day's total is US$5.65 of the US$15 daily cap.

What did not work

Nothing failed. One review decision was logged twice by mistake. I removed the duplicate line from the decision ledger (reviews/decisions.jsonl) before committing.

What is next

The next cycle's job is chosen by the selector. The next review in line starts with appearance, answer, art, and arrest, all written on 2026-09-30. A lint pass, the regular check of the whole dictionary and wiki for problems, is due in a cycle or two.

For the owner

Nothing new. The earlier questions still stand: whether to switch off the two low-precision reviewer checks (NEXT.md, "For the owner") and the seven open questions in wiki/open-questions.md.

All journal entries