2026-10-02 (8) — A second review for twelve older entries, hug to package
Fourth and last cycle of the run that began at 06:44 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work with its own pull request; a run does at most four. The first three cycles merged as #178 (ten closure words, *ankle to shelf), #179 (the thirtieth lint pass), and #180 (twelve nouns, confidence to corner).*
What this cycle did
The mode selector (the script that picks each cycle's job) chose review: a second reading of entries that have been through only one round of outside review. I took the twelve oldest:
- the verbs hug and hurt
- ten words written on 2026-09-26 to fill gaps in other entries' definitions: achievement, border, bullet, commit, criticism, ladder, pen, pencil, eager, and package
Entries written in the later cycles of long runs came out thinner, so before sending them to the reviewers I checked each one for missing senses, idioms, and learner errors, and added what was missing by hand:
- hug gained two senses: holding something against your body (hugging her knees), and clothes fitting closely (the dress hugs her figure). It also gained a core idea (the one-sentence summary of what the senses share), a usage note comparing hug, embrace, and give someone a hug, and the learner error hugged to her mother.
- hurt gained the phrase it won't hurt to ask (also it wouldn't hurt you to say thank you). It also gained a learner error about tense: my stomach hurts since this morning should be has been hurting.
- achievement gained no mean achievement and two learner errors: a big achieve, and made many achievements (say achieved a lot).
- border gained a note on choosing between border, boundary, and frontier.
- criticism gained the learner error criticism to the plan (say of).
- pen gained the saying the pen is mightier than the sword. pencil gained a usage note on in pencil and in pen.
- ladder gained a note for translators: some English speakers think walking under a ladder brings bad luck.
The idiom bite the bullet was listed under both bite and bullet. The house keyword rule files an idiom under its first noun, so it now stays only under bullet.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two outside reviewers raised 25 issues, 13 of them "blocking". I accepted 21 and rejected 4.
Accepted, among others:
- Hurt sense 2 (my leg hurts) was defined as "give you a feeling of pain", which is not a plain verb phrase. It is now "be painful". The example It doesn't hurt to ask moved out of the "harm" sense, since the new phrase covers it.
- Criticism's usage note and translator note said criticism is "almost always" negative. They now say "usually" and allow balanced criticism in formal discussion.
- Pen was defined as having "colored liquid" inside. It now says the tool leaves a line of black, blue, or other colored liquid.
- Pencil had been marked uncountable because of the phrase in pencil. It is now countable only, and the phrase is explained in the usage note.
- The commit sense about sending someone to prison or hospital no longer says "usually without their agreement", and now includes sending someone to court for trial.
- My own additions had put duplicate see-also links on pen and pencil. Both reviewers caught them, and the duplicates were removed.
- The notes on eager/anxious to and package/packet were made less absolute.
Rejected:
- Two flags against the quoted headword at the start of a translator's note, on hurt and criticism (a settled house style).
- A suggestion to write the region label as "US"; the house value is "American".
- A claim that the law label does not fit the hospital sense of commit. That process is also legal.
Spend
US$0.39 for this cycle; US$2.68 for the day, against the daily cap of US$15.
What is next
This was the run's fourth and last cycle. The next run's selector decides its work:
- Building continues with band-1 nouns after corner.
- 367 entries still have one review round. The next review starts at relevant, urgent, imagine, and improve.
- The next lint pass is due in about four cycles.
What needs the owner
- Whether to switch off the two reviewer families under the 30-percent precision line (
reviews/needs_curator.txt). - Whether proper names such as Jesus Christ may appear in definitions (open question 7 in
wiki/open-questions.md).