2026-10-02 (2) — Thirteenth originality check: no rewrites needed
Second cycle of the run that began at 00:43 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work with its own pull request; a run does up to four.
What this cycle did
The mode selector (the script that picks each cycle's job) forces an originality check every tenth run, and this was run 170. An originality check makes sure the dictionary's wording is its own and has not been copied, even by accident, from a published dictionary.
The check works like this:
- The tool
tools/originality_check.pypicks ten fields at random from the whole dictionary. This time all ten were definitions. - For each one, I ran a web search for the exact wording in quotation marks and looked only at whether a published dictionary shows the same words.
- I asked one of the outside reviewer models (reviewer-a) whether each definition reads as copied. It may answer "copied" only if it can quote the published wording.
Each field then gets one of three verdicts:
- original: no match.
- generic-overlap: a short, plain definition that any dictionary would write in much the same way. This is not copying.
- rewrite: a match with a published dictionary's distinctive wording. The field is then rewritten and reviewed again.
The ten definitions sampled were:
- represent, sense 4: "show or describe someone or something in a particular way, in a picture, a story, or a film"
- quit, sense 3: "close a computer program"
- cure, sense 2: "end a problem or a bad situation"
- all (pronoun), sense 2: "every person or thing in a group being talked about"
- family, sense 2: "all the people who are related to you, including grandparents, aunts, uncles, and cousins"
- either (pronoun), sense 1: "one or the other of two people or things, when it does not matter which"
- aircraft: "a vehicle that can fly, such as a plane"
- upon, sense 4: "used between two words that are the same to show a great number of things, one after another" (as in mile upon mile)
- without, sense 2: "not doing a particular thing"
- clean, sense 1: "remove dirt, dust, or marks from something"
What the search found
None of the ten wordings turned up in a published dictionary.
- Seven are original. The searches brought back unrelated pages: genealogy guides for family, cleaning and photo-editing guides for clean, pages about word repetition for upon.
- Three are generic overlap.
- quit: "close a computer program" is three plain words that any definer would use.
- either: one search summary gave a learner dictionary's wording, which uses the same key idea, "when it does not matter which". That idea is the rule itself, and the rest of our definition is worded differently.
- aircraft: a summary showed another dictionary starting "a vehicle which can fly, for example". "A vehicle that can fly" is the obvious short way to define the word, so this is the kind of overlap the style guide says is not copying. It sits close to the line, so I note it here in case the owner disagrees.
No rewrites were needed.
What the reviewer model did
reviewer-a answered "copied" for all ten, every time naming the same well-known learner dictionary. Each time, the "quotation" it gave was simply our own definition, word for word. Web search found none of them. Asking for a quote was meant to stop unsupported "copied" answers, and for several checks it seemed to work. This time it did not: a quote that is just our text repeated back proves nothing. As in the last five checks, the verdicts come from search evidence alone. I added a short entry about this to the reviewer-noise note (wiki/notes/reviewer-noise.md), where earlier patterns are recorded. The full record is reviews/originality/2026-10-02.md.
Spend
US$0.04, for the one reviewer call. The day's total is US$0.49 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Only the reviewer model, as described above. Its answer in this check is no help and costs little. If it keeps answering this way, a later run could drop the reviewer question from the check and use search alone. That would be a change to the checklist, so I have noted it rather than made it.
What is next
The selector picks the next cycle. The build queue goes on with the nouns after coin, and 357 entries still wait for a second review.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a decision. One optional judgment: aircraft is the closest call in this sample. If you would rather its definition were reworded anyway, a review run can do it.