2026-10-02 (16:43 UTC run, cycle 2): second review of twelve verbs, invest to lead
What this run did
This was the second cycle of the run that started at 16:43 UTC. The first cycle drafted twelve new verbs and was merged as pull request #186. For this cycle the mode selector (the script that chooses each cycle's kind of work) picked review. A review is a second reading of entries that have already passed one round of the outside reviewers. It looks for missing senses, idioms, learner errors, and usage notes, and then sends the entries through the reviewers again.
There were no unreviewed drafts, so the rule was to take the oldest entries that had been read only once. These were twelve verbs drafted on 2026-09-26: invest, invite, involve, join, judge, keep, kick, kill, kiss, know, lay, and lead. Earlier notes said that the verbs from that period often lacked usage notes and learner errors. That was true of most of these.
Before the reviewers saw them, I added by hand:
- Usage notes (a short paragraph on a point of use) to invest (which preposition goes with the money and which with the business), invite (invite someone to an event, for a meal), join, judge (judging by and judging from), kick, kill (people are killed in an accident; murder is only for a crime), know (not used in continuous tenses; get to know), and lead (the past form is led; lead to takes a noun or an -ing form).
- Learner errors: She invited me at her party (use to); I joined her birthday party, said by a guest (use went to); judge people with their clothes (use by); He kicked to the ball (no to).
- Nine idioms, each placed under the keyword rule (an idiom goes under the first noun in it, or the first verb when it has no noun): alive and kicking, kick someone when they're down, it won't kill you, kiss and make up, you never know, who knows, know better, not that I know of, and lead someone to believe something.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewer models raised 52 issues. Twenty-two were blocking, meaning I had to decide each one before the entries could stay marked as reviewed. I applied 25 decisions and rejected 27, and none needed to be escalated to the owner. Every decision is logged with its reason in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
The most useful findings were about judge. Four of its five definitions were either too narrow or too broad. One said a competition judge picks "the winner", when judges often rank everyone. One said guessing an amount is done only "by looking". The court sense said a judge "decides the result of a case", which ignores juries. All four were rewritten, and the court sense got a better example and its own collocations. Other changes I applied:
- kill meaning "be very angry" (Mom will kill me) now includes the idea of punishing, and is described as "usually" an exaggeration rather than "never" a real threat.
- The notes in lay had said it always takes an object, but the egg-laying sense does not need one (the hens are laying). The notes now say so.
- In lead, the learner error lead to increase prices could be read two ways. It is now lead to lose customers.
- The informal sense of invest (I finally invested in a good coat) now carries the informal label that its usage note already mentioned.
Most of the rejections were points the house rules already settle: the quoted headword at the start of an adaptation note, a stress mark placed after a syllable break, and a limit on a word's subject written in the explanation. One reviewer asked me to change the American pronunciation of lead to /lid/, which is exactly what the entry already says.
The basic-vocabulary check caught one definition that used criticize, which has no entry yet. I reworded it.
Spend
US$0.59 for this cycle. Spend today is US$5.27 of the US$15 daily cap.
What is next
The selector will choose the next cycle. The next entries due for review are learn, leave, let, lie, lift and the ones after them. 379 entries have still had only one review round.
For the owner
Nothing new. The questions listed in NEXT.md are still open.