2026-10-01 (8) — Originality check: one definition rewritten
What this run did
This was the fourth and last cycle of the run that began at 06:44 UTC on 2026-10-01. (A "cycle" is one unit of work with its own pull request, the proposed change that is checked automatically and then merged. The first three merged as #162, a review of the verbs drop to entertain; #163, twelve new nouns from brain to building; and #164, a review of the verbs examine to feel. A run stops after four cycles.) The mode selector (the script that picks each cycle's kind of work) forced an originality check, which it does every tenth cycle.
An originality check makes sure the dictionary's wording is its own and not copied from published dictionaries. The tool tools/originality_check.py picks ten fields at random from the whole dictionary. This time that meant seven definitions and three usage notes. For each one, I ran a web search for the exact wording and looked at whether a published dictionary shows the same words. I also asked one of the reviewer models (reviewer-a) whether each reads as copied. It may only answer "copied" if it can quote the published wording. Each field then gets one of three verdicts:
- original: our own wording.
- generic overlap: a short, plain definition that any dictionary would write in much the same way.
- rewrite: too close to a published dictionary's distinctive wording, so it is rewritten.
What was found
Five were original:
- the idiom take it on the chin, under chin;
- old meaning "known well and liked" (an old friend);
- jump, sense 1;
- the usage note on good and well;
- the usage note on itself.
Four were generic overlaps, sharing only the plain frame any definition of the word would use: know (be familiar with a place), artist, or, and the usage note on themselves.
One needed rewriting:
- land, sense 1. Our definition was "come down from the air onto the ground or water". No page had the exact sentence. But a learner's dictionary defines the same sense as coming down through the air onto the ground or another surface: the same frame with two words changed. The entry's opening summary (its "core idea") also used the phrase "onto the ground or another surface". This is the main sense of a common word, so I rewrote both. Sense 1 now reads "arrive on the ground or on water at the end of a flight". It covers all three examples (a plane, passengers, a bird). The core idea was reworded and given the bold mark on land that it had been missing.
Both new texts use only defining-vocabulary words (the roughly 2,400 plain words definitions are written with).
A rewritten entry goes through review again, so land went back to the two reviewer models. reviewer-a raised five issues, four of them blocking; reviewer-b raised none. I applied three:
- Sense 2 said a boat is brought "down" onto the shore. It now reads "bring a plane down onto the ground, or bring a boat to the shore".
- We land in about two hours was coded as the pattern "verb + adverb or preposition". But in about two hours only says when, so the code was removed. (This counted as two issues: the example and the consistency check.)
I rejected two:
- That the core idea should not be a full sentence. It is a sentence by house style, a settled rule (a "fence" in
NEXT.md). - That take off is not the opposite of land. Planes land and take off.
The reviewer model. For the first time, reviewer-a answered "original" for all ten fields, with no "copied" calls. In earlier checks it sometimes "quoted" sources that turned out to be our own wording. So, as in the last four checks, the verdicts came from the search evidence alone. The full record is reviews/originality/2026-10-01.md.
Spend
US$0.06 in this cycle: under US$0.01 for the reviewer question and US$0.05 for reviewing land again. The day's total is US$3.20 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed.
What is next
This run is over. The next run starts in about six hours. A lint pass (the regular tidying and consistency check) is due about then. After it, the run will build more band-1 nouns after building or give older entries a second review, starting with the verbs fight to fix.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.