2026-09-28 (3) — Review: fifteen verbs, peel to protect
What this run did
This was the third cycle of the scheduled run that began at 00:44 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work, checked, recorded, and merged on its own. The first two cycles' pull requests (#110 and #111) merged before this one started. The mode selector (the script that decides what each cycle does) chose review for the third time: a second reading of entries that have passed the reviewer panel only once.
The block was fifteen verbs written late on 2026-09-26: peel, perform, pick, place, plan, play, pour, practice, praise, pray, press, prevent, produce, pronounce, and protect.
I read each one before sending it to the panel and added common uses that were missing:
- pick: a new sense, eat only small amounts of food, slowly, because you are not hungry (She just picked at her dinner).
- place: a new sense for finishing a race in a position (She placed third in the race).
- play: a new sense, act as if you were something that you are not (The dog rolled over and played dead; Don't play innocent with me), and the informal phrase play it cool.
- pour: a subsense for putting a lot of money or effort into something (She poured all her energy into the business).
- press: a subsense for flattening something or squeezing liquid out of it (press flowers, press grapes).
My first wording for the new play sense used pretend and behave. Neither is in the defining vocabulary (the list of plain words definitions are written in), and neither has an entry yet. The vocabulary check caught this, and I reworded the definition before the panel saw it.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewer models raised 24 issues, 14 of them "blocking" (the entry cannot stay marked reviewed until a decision is logged). I decided all 24: 15 applied and 9 rejected. Each decision is in reviews/decisions.jsonl. This panel was more useful than the last one: most of the first reviewer's blocking points were right.
Changes I accepted:
- peel: sense 2 joined two different uses in one definition: paint peeling by itself, and someone peeling a label off. They are now a sense and a subsense, each with the right grammar.
- play: three definitions were reworded. "act a character" became "take the part of a character". A definition with a semicolon in the middle was rewritten. play it safe began "not take risks", but a verb definition should start with a verb, so it is now "be careful and do what is least likely to go wrong".
- practice: the learner-error note said the verb is followed by the -ing form. That is true only when another verb follows; practice the piano takes a noun. The note now says so.
- plan: aim was listed as a synonym of the "think ahead" sense. Both reviewers said it belongs with "intend", and it has moved there.
- pick: the fruit-and-flowers sense now also covers vegetables and leaves. The note comparing pick with choose now calls pick "a little less formal", not "more informal".
- prevent: both reviewers questioned guard as a synonym. The guard entry has a sense meaning guard against something, so I kept the link and added a note saying that.
- pour and praise: a clearer subsense definition and a better example.
What I rejected, and why:
- The first reviewer wanted the British forms practised and practising in practice's inflections. The forms follow the American headword; the British spelling practise is already recorded as a variant.
- It wanted a literary label on pray meaning hope. I just pray that he's safe is ordinary spoken English.
- The second reviewer said you shell an egg rather than peel it. Peel an egg and peel shrimp are everyday English.
- One-sentence summaries at the top of an entry (the core idea) take a sentence form by house style, and translators' notes open with a quoted headword by house convention; these objections were rejected again.
Spend
This cycle's panel cost US$0.55. The day's total is US$1.69 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The pronunciation check was not re-run, because no transcription changed.
What is next
The last four late-cycle verbs, prove, provide, pull, and punish, then the nouns and adjectives added from the dictionary's own definitions late on 2026-09-26. 315 entries still have only one review round.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. Open questions 4, 5 and 6 in wiki/open-questions.md are still waiting for you.