2026-09-28 (2) — Review: fifteen verbs, need to pay
What this run did
This was the second cycle of the scheduled run that began at 00:44 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work, checked, recorded, and merged on its own; the first cycle's pull request (#110) merged before this one started. The mode selector (the script that decides what each cycle does) chose review again: a second reading of entries that have passed the reviewer panel only once.
The block was fifteen verbs written late on 2026-09-26: need, notice, obey, observe, occur, open, operate, order, owe, own, pack, paint, park, pass, and pay.
I read each one before sending it to the panel. Most were in good shape; six lacked a common use, which I added by hand:
- open: two subsenses. One is for spreading something apart, as in open your mouth, open an umbrella, or open a book; the entry had only covered doors, windows, and lids. The other is for a play, a film, or an event beginning (The new play opens next week).
- owe: the phrase owe it to someone to do something (You owe it to yourself to take a real vacation).
- pack: a subsense for crowding into a space (Six of us packed into the tiny car).
- pass: a new informal sense, decide not to take something that is offered, as in "More cake?" "I'll pass, thanks."
- pay: a subsense for a job giving a certain amount of money (The job pays well, but the hours are long).
- paint: an example with nails, She painted her nails bright red.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewer models raised 33 issues, 19 of them "blocking" (the entry cannot stay marked reviewed until a decision is logged). I decided all 33: 8 applied and 25 rejected. Each decision is in reviews/decisions.jsonl. That is a high rejection rate. Most of the rejected issues repeated a few objections, listed below.
Changes I accepted:
- need: the one-sentence summary at the top of the entry said "to have to have or do something", which reads badly. It now says "to find it necessary: to have it, to do it, or to have it done".
- open: a note for translators said English uses turn on, not open, for lights, televisions, and taps. Open the tap does occur in British English, so taps were taken out of the note.
- pay: the new subsense's definition, "give a particular amount of money to the person who does it", was unclear about who "the person" is. It now reads "give the worker a particular amount of money". Pay in, which usually means putting money into a bank account, was removed from the first sense's collocations.
- Smaller fixes: collocations were completed for operate (operate normally, operate on gas) and reorganized for pack. A passive example in order lost a label that described the active pattern.
What I rejected, and why:
- The first reviewer objected to the "not used in continuous tenses" grammar marker on need and own, and to the learner errors I am needing and I am owning a house. The dictionary's grammar code describes normal use. The learner-error notes already say "not normally", which covers the rare exceptions.
- The second reviewer objected that three definitions of need begin with must or should. Those definitions replace the word cleanly in a sentence (I need a phone / I must have a phone) and are the plainest wording available.
- The first reviewer said It's easy to operate shows an intransitive use. It does not: the object is understood (easy to operate it).
- It said she painted the wall with yellow is not a real error. Learners do say it, and the natural English is painted the wall yellow.
- It objected to give as a synonym of pay and run as a word to compare with own. I gave him ten dollars for it is ordinary English, and learners do confuse own a shop with run a shop.
- The second reviewer again objected, six times, to the quoted headword at the start of translators' notes, which is a settled house convention.
Spend
This cycle's panel cost US$0.54. The day's total is US$1.15 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. The pronunciation check was not re-run, because no transcription changed.
What is next
The next review should take the 19 verbs from peel to punish, then the nouns and adjectives added from the dictionary's own definitions late on 2026-09-26. 330 entries still have only one review round.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. Open questions 4, 5 and 6 in wiki/open-questions.md are still waiting for you.