2026-09-28 (11) — Review: five conjunctions and six early verbs
What this run did
This was the third cycle of the scheduled run that began at 12:44 UTC. (A "cycle" is one unit of work with its own pull request, merged before the next begins.) The first two cycles, a review of the modal verbs (#118) and a lint pass (#119), had already merged.
The mode selector chose review: a second reading by the reviewer panel (two outside language models that check every field) of entries read only once. I took the eleven oldest: the conjunctions when, where, whether, while, and yet, and the verbs appeal, appear, apply, argue, arrest, and arrive, all written on 2026-09-22.
The verbs were correct but thin. None had a learner-error box or a usage note. Before sending anything to the panel, I added material by hand:
- Verbs:
- The mistakes learners really make: The idea appeals me, I applied a job, He applied for three universities (should be to), She appeared nervously, She argued her brother, arrested because of stealing, We arrived to the hotel, arrived to home.
- Short usage notes: apply for the thing you want, apply to the place you ask; arrive in a city, arrive at a building.
- Missing senses: appeal to someone's feelings, appear for something beginning to exist (Cracks began to appear), arrive for deliveries, babies, and success (she had finally arrived).
- One example named a real city, which house rules keep out of examples; it now says "the city".
- Conjunctions:
- when for a sudden event (I was just leaving when the phone rang) and for short forms (when necessary, when in doubt), and the phrase say when.
- while with an -ing form (while driving), and the very common error During I was waiting.
- yet with the error Although he was tired, yet he kept working.
- Some signposts were too long. A signpost is the short label that helps a reader pick a sense; the house limit is three words. yet has only one sense, so its signpost was cleared, as the style guide requires.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The reviewers raised 43 issues. I applied 33 and rejected 10.
The main finding was a real mistake of mine. I had added a sense to when and where for reported questions (I don't know where she lives), with the word-order error Do you know where is the station? Both reviewers said independently that this use belongs to the question words when and where, which the dictionary treats as adverbs, and not to the conjunctions. The entries already pointed to those adverb entries for questions, so they contradicted themselves. I removed the senses and recorded the rule in NEXT.md so later runs follow it. when and where as adverbs are already in the queue, and the note tells whoever drafts them to include this use and its error. (whether is different: it has no adverb and stays a conjunction.)
Other changes I accepted:
- Definitions: where, while, and yet each had a contrast definition made of loose synonyms ("but, at the same time"). All three now use the house pattern for function words: "used to set one fact against another...".
- appeal: the most common senses (be attractive, ask the public for help) now come before the legal one.
- argue: I had claimed that discuss means talking calmly. It does not always, so that claim is gone.
- Smaller fixes: collocations for arrest (arrest the decline); the arrive sense for times and events now keeps its subject restriction in the explanation, as house rules require; a clearer example for appear on stage.
What I rejected:
- A claim that appealed for witnesses to come forward is wrong. It is a standard pattern.
- A claim that doesn't apply in my case is wrong. It is natural English.
- A claim that the sudden-event when is not a sense of its own. The clauses swap roles there, and many languages translate it differently.
- Straight apostrophes and sentence-style summaries, which are house style.
Spend
The panel cost US$0.40. The day's total is US$3.84 of the US$15 daily cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. After my first pass, the cross-reference tool found that once named when as a synonym while when named once as a word to compare. I made both sides synonyms.
What is next
257 entries still have one review round. Next are assume, attack, bake, and beat, then the verbs from believe to board.
What needs the owner
Nothing new. Open questions 4 to 6 still wait for you.