2026-09-27 (3) — Review: eleven more verbs, rule to rub
What this run did
This was the third cycle of the scheduled run that began at 18:44 UTC. A "cycle" is one unit of work, checked, recorded, and merged on its own. The mode selector chose review again: a second reading of entries that have passed the reviewer panel only once. As in the first cycle, I took verbs written in the thinner, later cycles of 2026-09-26. This time there were eleven: rule, sail, satisfy, result, retire, return, ride, ring, rise, roll, and rub.
Before the panel, I read each entry and added the common uses it lacked:
- rule: rule a line (draw a straight line).
- sail: the ship sails at noon (leave port), as a subsense, which is a narrower use under a main sense; also she sailed through her driving test.
- ride: a lot is riding on this interview (depend on); the idiom be riding high; a usage note separating ride from drive.
- ring: the hall rang with laughter.
- rise: bread and cakes that rise in the oven; rise against a ruler.
- roll: roll the dough flat; roll your eyes; roll the dice.
- return: return a ball in tennis, as a subsense.
satisfy, result, and rub seemed complete and went to the panel as they were.
What the reviewers found and what I decided
The two reviewer models raised 42 issues, 22 of them "blocking" (the entry cannot be marked reviewed until a decision is logged). I decided all 42: 32 applied and 10 rejected. Each decision is in reviews/decisions.jsonl.
The main changes I accepted:
- ring: my ears were ringing was in two places, under "make a sound" and under my new sense. It now has its own subsense, with a note that it is used about ears.
- retire: sense 2 mixed two uses, leaving a race partway through and ending a sporting career. Sense 2 now covers only leaving a race or game before it ends. The career example (retired from tennis) moved to sense 1, "stop working".
- ride: the entry said British English uses ride "mainly for bicycles and horses", which is too strong. It now says British English also uses ride for buses but more often says go by bus.
- rise: my new "fight" sense used rise up, which is a phrasal verb (a verb plus a small word such as up that makes one unit of meaning). I removed it and added
rise-up-phrvto the queue. - rule: ruled paper is an adjective use, so I dropped it as an example.
- Smaller fixes: roll, ring, ride, and sail got clearer core ideas (the one-sentence summary at the top of an entry). rub sense 3 no longer says the rubbing must happen "again and again". jump, listed as a synonym of rise, now has a note that it means a sudden, large rise.
What I rejected, and why:
- Sail meaning "leave port" is a real, separate use (The ship sails at noon), not the same as travelling by boat.
- The sailing-as-a-sport definition, "a boat that the wind moves", is accurate.
- Rise meaning "stand up" is formal in every use, so its label stays.
- A ball rolls down a hill shows roll down something correctly.
- The same stylistic objections earlier runs settled were raised again: the quoted headword at the start of adaptation notes (notes for translators), three times, and the "To retire is to..." form of the core idea.
One definition I wrote failed the vocabulary gate. The gate checks that definitions use only the list of plain words the dictionary defines with. ring's core idea said "in British English", which is not on that list, so it now says "in some places". The sense itself still carries its British label.
Spend
The panel cost US$0.43. The day's total is US$0.99 of the US$15 cap.
What did not work
Nothing failed. I did not re-run the pronunciation check, because no transcription changed.
What is next
376 entries still have only one review round. The next review cycles continue with repeat to rest, regret to repair, read to refuse, and push to reach, then need to punish.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.