2026-09-26 (fifth run): a second reading of eighteen entries
What this run did
This was a review run, the second cycle of this session. The first cycle was the originality check in journal/2026-09-26-4.md. A review run gives entries that have been reviewed only once a second reading. The two outside reviewer models read every field of each entry again. The run then judges each issue they raise: it accepts it and fixes the entry ("apply"), or turns it down with a written reason ("reject").
The block was the oldest once-reviewed entries: eleven pronouns from 19 September (someone, something, theirs, them, themselves, these, they, this, those, us, we), four nouns and an adjective from the same day (exception, identity, thumb, addition, additional, article), and over (preposition). over was added because the originality check had just found that its second sense opened with a stock phrase, "from one side of something to the other". That sense was reworded before the panel read it, to "above something or along its top, to the other side of it".
What the reviewers found and what was decided
There were 27 issues, 12 of them blocking (must be settled before an entry counts as reviewed). The run applied 20 and rejected 7.
The main finding was a real error in the grammar advice for someone and something. Both entries said that in questions English uses anyone or anything, "not did someone call?". Each also listed a natural question (Did someone see my keys?, Did something go wrong?) as a learner error. That is wrong. Someone and something are normal in questions that expect the answer yes, and in offers and requests (Is something wrong? Would you like something to drink? Could someone help me?). One reviewer caught it on someone and the other on something. The explanation, the comparison note, and the note for translators were rewritten in both entries so that they say the same thing, and the false learner errors were removed. A search found the same flaw in somebody, which was not in the block. It was fixed the same way and sent to the panel on its own, where both reviewers passed it with no issues.
Other fixes:
- themselves in its emphatic use (they painted the house themselves) no longer claims it always means "and no one else".
- these now covers things just mentioned, not only things being talked about "right now".
- addition in the sense of a person or thing added no longer says it makes the group "better". The phrase do addition was replaced with the more natural practice addition and learn addition.
- article (a piece of writing) now covers magazines as well as newspapers and websites. The definition now reads "... that appears in a newspaper, on a website, or in something similar".
- take exception to something now means "object strongly to something someone says or does, because it seems rude or unfair", not just "be angry or upset".
- us: the second sense (give us a hand, meaning me) no longer repeats the word "informally" that its label already gives, and a usage note that repeated the first sense's explanation was removed.
- they: an example sentence that talked about the words he and she as words was replaced with an ordinary sentence.
- over: an unfitting collocation, look over the wall, was removed.
Rejected, each with a reason:
- Two requests to capitalize the short quoted phrases in explanations. House style keeps them lowercase.
- Two objections to where the stress mark sits in exception's transcription. The project settled this earlier.
- An objection that the "room built onto a house" sense of addition is not only American. The label means "mainly used there", and British English usually says extension.
- A claim that prefer something over something is not careful usage. It is common American English.
- A reviewer's doubt about the learner error These is my books. The error is real.
Spend
US$0.55 this run: US$0.53 for the eighteen-entry panel and US$0.02 for somebody. That is under this cycle's US$1.25 ceiling. The day's total is US$1.78 of the US$15 cap.
What is next
About 344 entries still have only one review. The next oldest are the prepositions and pronouns from 20 September (about, above, after, against and others). When a run opens anyone, anybody, or anything, it should check that they agree with the corrected advice here. Band-1 building continues after introduce, and a lint pass (periodic tidy-up) is due soon.
For the owner
Nothing new needs you. Open questions 4, 5, and 6 in wiki/open-questions.md still wait on you.