2026-09-26 (twenty-seventh run): a second reading of 16 older entries
What this run did
This was the eighth cycle of this session, and a review run. A review run adds no new words. It sends existing entries back to the two reviewer models for a second reading. Entries from the dictionary's first week were read only once, and a second round often finds what the first missed. The block was the next 16 entries by creation date, from bad, off, out, and per (2026-09-20) to surround (2026-09-21).
What the reviewers found and what was decided
The reviewers raised 39 issues. Each has a logged decision: 31 applied and 8 rejected. Seven entries came back clean: bad, arrangement, contact, lean, pressure, role, and the adjective concerning, apart from one rejected point.
The big one: out (preposition). Almost all of this entry was really about out of: out of the house, out of milk, made out of wood, out of kindness. It also said three things that are wrong:
- that out from the house is always wrong (out from under the bed is normal English)
- that out is "never" used alone before a noun
- that out the house is an error in every case
Both reviewers objected. Reviewer-b pointed out that in American English, the dictionary's main variety, bare out is standard before door and window: She looked out the window, He ran out the door.
The entry now has a new first sense, "through a door, a window, or another opening", labelled American, with three examples. The out of senses stay. The usage note, the learner error, and the translator's note were rewritten to match. The learner error is now He ran out the house (corrected to out of the house), because bare out is used mainly with doors and windows. Reviewer-a also wanted out of milk treated as an adjective. That was rejected: out of plus a noun is the compound preposition the entry is about.
Other fixes:
- off: the example She was off school with a cold and the phrase off school are British. They were replaced with off duty. A pronunciation note said off has the same vowel as dog and long, which is true only in some American accents. It now just explains how off differs from of. The "stay off coffee" subsense now includes medical reasons.
- per, sense 2 (per your request), was defined as "in the way stated by", which is too vague. It now reads "in the way that a rule, a plan, or a request says". A note referred to "Sense 2" by number and now names the sense.
- concerning (preposition): the definition joined two definitions with a semicolon, and the explanation called about "too casual" for formal writing. Both were fixed.
- surround in the mystery surrounding her disappearance was defined as making something "seem more uncertain or interesting", which is not always true. It is now "be present around an event, a situation, or a person, as feelings, questions, or talk about it". Its core idea and signpost were simplified.
- enclosed had two senses but a signpost (the short label that helps a reader pick a sense) on only one. The missing one was added.
- feature, opposed: small definition fixes.
- opposition and contact: the American transcriptions had a length mark on the vowel of hot. The house leaves length marks out of American transcriptions, so they were removed, and both were checked again and verified.
Rejected: reviewer-a's request for a plural of opposition, since both senses in the entry are uncountable or singular only. Also rejected: a request to repeat the formal label on a sense when the whole entry already carries it.
While running the cross-reference tool, the run also applied eight back-links from older entries to this session's verbs remove, remain, and require. Back-links are links pointing back from one entry to another that already names it. Examples are add and install as opposites of remove, and keep and continue as synonyms of remain. All eight were checked and are on the right senses.
Spend
US$0.50 for this run (reviewer calls), US$8.49 so far today, against the daily cap of US$15.
What is next
The next review block starts with one (pronoun) and accident. NEXT.md now records how out is split, so a later review does not undo it.
What needs the owner
Nothing new.