2026-09-26 (tenth run): a second reading of twenty prepositions and pronouns
What this run did
This was the fourth cycle of this session and a review run. A review run gives existing entries a second reading by the two reviewer models. Every entry is reviewed once before it is published. Since the dictionary has grown, the scheduler (next_mode.py) now alternates new building with second readings, oldest first. The first three cycles built thirty new verbs (pull requests #76, #77 and #78).
The block was the twenty oldest entries that had had only one reading, all from 2026-09-20:
- prepositions: about, above, after, against, along, among, around, as, at, before;
- pronouns: neither, nobody, none, some, which, who, whom, whose, you, yours.
Function words like these are short entries, but they are where learners' grammar questions concentrate.
Before the reviewers read them, one entry was tidied by hand. As (preposition) has only one sense but carried a signpost. A signpost is the short label that helps a reader pick a sense from a list, so a one-sense entry should not have one. It was removed. Forty-one other entries still have this problem and are fixed as reviews reach them.
What the reviewers found and what was decided
The reviewers raised 57 issues. Each was read against the entry and got a logged decision: 43 fixes applied and 14 rejected. Three entries (before, whose, yours) came through with no issues.
Claims that were too absolute. The most useful findings were statements stronger than the facts:
- which: the entry said American English "normally uses that" in a clause with no comma. It now says that is more common there and many style guides prefer it. It adds that which is still correct, and is the only choice directly after a preposition (the house in which I grew up).
- whom: the entry said it "cannot be replaced" after a preposition. It now says careful English uses whom there.
- among: the learner error called share the cake between the six children wrong. Both reviewers said it is normal English, so the error was replaced with a real one: divided among the two brothers → between the two brothers.
- neither: the correction implied that only a singular verb is right, although the entry itself says a plural verb is also standard. That is fixed.
House-rule problems. Two explanations, in nobody and whom, showed a wrong form in italics (nobody doesn't know, to who I spoke). The house rule is that wrong forms appear only in the learner-error box, so both were rewritten. Neither pointed readers to its determiner entry for neither ... nor; the house rule gives correlative pairs a conjunction entry, so it now points to neither (conjunction).
Smaller fixes. None too is now defined as "not very" and lost its "informal" label. Some gained a weak spoken form. Two definitions were narrower than their own examples and were widened: after ("coming behind in place or order") and about ("in or to different parts of a place", now labeled British). At sense 2 was rewritten, because the old wording was not a phrase that could replace the word.
Rejected. Reviewer-a called several examples adverbs or adjectives, although each has an object after the preposition (about the office, above ours, he's above that). They are preposition uses, so the objections were rejected. Its requests to move be about to out of the adjective treatment, and to treat around fifty dollars as a preposition, were rejected to keep the dictionary consistent with decisions already in force. It also asked to move above all to another entry. The house keyword rule puts that phrase under above, so it stayed.
Spend
US$0.55, all for the review panel. Today's total is US$3.66, well under the daily limit of US$15.
What did not work
Nothing failed. One tool reported slightly different counts of applied and rejected decisions than a first hand count; the tool's figures (43 and 14) were checked against the decision list and are the ones used here.
What is next
The next review block starts with yourself and the next prepositions (behind, between, by, down). The scheduler will force a lint pass (the housekeeping check over the whole dictionary) within the next run or so. Building continues after manage.
For the owner
Nothing new needs a decision.